UK Employer Guide: Pay & Deductions

Ensuring that workers are paid correctly and on time is one of the most important legal responsibilities for any UK employer. A wide framework of legislation governs pay accuracy, minimum pay entitlements, itemised payslips, statutory sick pay, workplace pensions and the limited situations in which deductions from wages are allowed. Employers must also understand how to approach final pay when employment ends, how to deal with additional hours and mandatory training, and how bonuses, commission, expenses, tips and pension contributions sit within wider payroll compliance. Failures in any of these areas can quickly give rise to unlawful deduction claims, HMRC enforcement activity, financial penalties and broader employee relations issues.

This guide is aimed at HR professionals, business owners and payroll leads who need a clear, practical explanation of the UK legal rules around pay and deductions. It sets out the minimum standards all employers must meet, highlights common risk areas that lead to disputes or claims and explains how to design payroll processes that are consistent, transparent and legally compliant. Each section focuses on a specific aspect of pay law – from minimum wage and sick pay through to tips, commission, expenses and pensions – so that employers can build systems and policies that protect both the organisation and its workforce. Where statutory rights differ as between employees and other workers, this is flagged so that the correct standard can be applied.

The rest of this article takes a structured look at the full range of employer responsibilities relating to pay. It starts with minimum wage law, then moves through key statutory and contractual entitlements such as sick pay and payslips, before turning to more complex areas including non-payment of wages, deductions, final pay, overtime, mandatory training, pay rises, bonuses, commission, expenses, tips and workplace pension duties. Throughout, the focus is on legal accuracy, clarity and practical guidance to support effective HR and payroll practice.

Section A: National Minimum Wage

UK employers must ensure that every worker receives at least the applicable National Minimum Wage (NMW) or National Living Wage (NLW) for each pay reference period. This obligation applies regardless of business size, sector practice or financial circumstances. Because compliance is assessed over the pay reference period, even relatively small errors or omissions can reduce average hourly pay below the legal threshold and expose the employer to arrears, penalties and reputational damage.

1. Minimum wage structure and applicable rates

The minimum wage regime sets different hourly rates according to a worker’s age and category, with a separate rate structure for apprentices. Employers must identify which rate applies to each worker and ensure that changes in age band or status are reflected promptly in payroll. Where a worker moves into a higher age band part-way through a pay reference period, the higher rate must apply from the date of the change. Apprentice entitlements are particularly technical: eligibility for the apprentice rate, and the point at which a higher NMW rate becomes due, depend on both age and where the apprentice is within their programme.

Minimum wage rates are updated periodically, typically each April. Employers must keep payroll systems, written documentation and communications up to date with the latest figures. Failure to apply new rates on time is a frequent cause of inadvertent underpayments, especially in organisations with large, multi-site or shift-based workforces.

2. Working time, records and common risk areas

Accurate minimum wage calculations depend on correctly identifying what counts as “working time” for NMW purposes. This is often where compliance risk arises. Depending on the facts, working time may include:

• Time spent performing duties during a shift.
• Mandatory induction and job-related training, even if completed outside normal hours or on non-working days.
• Certain waiting time where the worker is required to be available for work or remain at a specified place.
• Travel between assignments or work locations where travel is required as part of the role.
• On-call time where the worker is required to remain at, or very close to, the workplace or is otherwise significantly constrained by the employer’s requirements.

By contrast, normal commuting between home and a single, fixed workplace will not usually count as working time for minimum wage purposes, although travel between different work sites during the working day generally will. Employers should assess working patterns carefully, particularly in sectors involving mobile workers, overnight work or standby arrangements.

Employers must also keep reliable records of hours worked and pay received so that they can demonstrate compliance if challenged. The statutory minimum record-keeping period for NMW purposes is three years, but many employers choose to retain pay and hours records for up to six years to mirror limitation periods for wage claims. In practice, where there is a dispute about underpayment, an employer who cannot produce adequate records is likely to struggle to rebut an allegation of non-compliance.

3. Deductions, worker-borne costs and accommodation

Deductions from wages and certain costs met by workers themselves can affect whether minimum wage has been paid. Some deductions are ignored entirely for NMW purposes, while others count negatively and can inadvertently cause average pay to fall below the legal minimum.

In particular, sums which are regarded as “for the employer’s own use or benefit” – such as compulsory uniforms, tools, equipment, some types of work-related travel between sites and administrative charges – will reduce pay when calculating whether NMW or NLW has been met. Where workers must pay for these items, employers must check that the remaining pay across the reference period continues to meet or exceed the applicable rate. If it does not, the employer will have underpaid the minimum wage even if the worker’s headline rate appears compliant.

The accommodation rules create a further area of complexity. Where an employer provides living accommodation, only a specified daily amount – known as the accommodation offset – can be treated as part of pay for NMW purposes. The offset is reviewed periodically and is subject to an upper cap. If the notional value of the accommodation exceeds the offset, the excess will in effect reduce pay for minimum wage calculations and can lead to underpayment. Employers who provide accommodation must therefore keep a close eye on offset levels and ensure that payroll calculations reflect the latest figures.

4. Enforcement, arrears and corrective action

Where underpayments are identified, employers should correct them without delay. As a matter of HMRC enforcement policy, arrears are typically calculated by reference to the current applicable NMW or NLW rate, rather than the historic rate that applied when the underpayment originally occurred. This can significantly increase the cost of remediation and should be factored into risk assessments. Tribunals may approach arrears differently depending on the nature of the claim, but HMRC has wide powers to require repayment of arrears and to impose penalties.

HMRC can investigate suspected breaches, issue enforcement notices, levy financial penalties and, in appropriate cases, publish the names of non-compliant employers. Public “naming” exercises can cause reputational harm even where underpayments arose from genuine mistakes rather than deliberate underpayment. Businesses that rely heavily on low-paid, part-time or variable hours staff are particularly exposed if time recording and payroll processes are not robust.

Good practice is to carry out regular internal reviews of working time records, deductions, uniform and equipment policies, travel and accommodation arrangements and any other costs which might impact minimum wage calculations. Employers should ensure that line managers, HR and payroll understand the NMW framework, and that systems allow potential issues to be identified and corrected quickly. Clear documentation, up-to-date contracts and transparent communication with workers all help to demonstrate that the employer takes minimum wage compliance seriously.

Section B: Sick Pay

Sick pay is a key statutory protection for eligible staff and a frequent source of legal and employee-relations risk if handled incorrectly. UK employers must administer statutory sick pay (SSP) in line with the legislation, understand how it interacts with any contractual sick pay arrangements and ensure that decisions about evidence, eligibility and duration are applied consistently. Errors in this area can lead to unlawful deduction of wages claims, disputes over absence management and, in some cases, allegations of discrimination.

SSP provides a basic level of income for qualifying individuals who are unable to work due to illness. It sits alongside any enhanced or contractual sick pay that an employer chooses to offer. Because SSP rights attach to individuals who fall within the statutory definition of “employee” for SSP purposes, employers cannot simply rely on how a contract labels the relationship; the underlying facts and working arrangements will often be more important than the job title.

1. Statutory sick pay framework

SSP is payable to eligible employees who are off work due to sickness for at least four consecutive qualifying days, forming what is known as a Period of Incapacity for Work. SSP is not payable for the first three qualifying days of such a period unless the rules on linked periods apply, in which case earlier absences can be aggregated. Payments are subject to statutory maximums, including an overall limit on the number of weeks for which SSP can be paid.

To qualify, the employee must normally:

• Be an “employee” for SSP purposes and have done some work under their contract.
• Have average weekly earnings at or above the Lower Earnings Limit for National Insurance.
• Be absent from work due to illness for at least four consecutive qualifying days.
• Not have exhausted their overall SSP entitlement for the relevant period.

Qualifying days are usually the days on which the employee would normally work, although an alternative pattern can be agreed. Employers must be clear and consistent about which days count as qualifying days, as this directly affects when SSP starts and stops.

2. Evidence, notification and eligibility decisions

Employers are entitled to require reasonable evidence that an employee is unfit for work, but the rules on timing and type of evidence must be followed. In many cases, self-certification for the first seven calendar days of absence is sufficient, with medical fit notes required thereafter. Requiring a doctor’s note earlier than this can be problematic unless it is clearly justified and consistent with statutory guidance.

Clear notification procedures are equally important. Employees should know how and when they must report sickness, who they should contact and what information they need to provide. Employers should apply these rules consistently and be cautious about withholding SSP purely because notification rules were not followed, especially where the employee can show good reason for delay. Decisions that appear overly rigid or inconsistent can increase the risk of grievances, claims of unfair treatment or arguments that contractual trust and confidence has been undermined.

Where an individual does not qualify for SSP – for example, because their average earnings are below the threshold or they have already received the maximum SSP period – employers should explain this clearly and provide information about any alternative options that might be available. Confusion about entitlement is a common trigger for disputes and complaints.

3. Contractual and enhanced sick pay schemes

Many employers operate contractual or “company” sick pay schemes that provide pay above SSP levels or for longer periods. These enhanced arrangements can be a valuable part of the overall reward package, but they must be clearly documented and administered carefully.

Key points for employers include:

• Setting out the terms of any enhanced scheme in contracts, handbooks or policies, including eligibility criteria, waiting periods and maximum entitlement.
• Explaining how contractual sick pay interacts with SSP, for example whether SSP is included within or paid on top of company sick pay.
• Applying scheme rules consistently to avoid arguments that policies have been operated in a discriminatory or arbitrary manner.
• Ensuring that decisions to withhold or reduce contractual sick pay – for example due to misconduct or failure to follow procedures – are evidence-based and in line with the wording of the scheme.

Where both SSP and contractual sick pay are payable, employers must ensure that the combined payments do not fall below statutory minimums. They must also be clear about when contractual sick pay ends and what happens if absence continues, particularly in long-term sickness cases.

4. Payroll treatment, record keeping and discrimination risk

SSP is paid through the employer’s payroll and is subject to tax and National Insurance in broadly the same way as ordinary wages. Employers cannot usually recover SSP from the state under current rules, so errors in calculation or administration are likely to be borne directly by the business. Payroll teams must ensure that SSP is triggered on the correct day, that payments do not exceed the statutory maximum period and that any interaction with contractual sick pay is recorded accurately.

Accurate absence records are essential. Employers should maintain clear logs of sickness dates, qualifying days, evidence received, decisions made and payments processed. This not only supports correct payroll treatment but also provides an audit trail if entitlement is challenged or if regulators or tribunals later scrutinise the employer’s approach.

Managing sick pay also has an equality and discrimination dimension. Where sickness absence is linked to a disability, pregnancy, maternity or other protected characteristic, employers must take particular care. Applying policies in a way that disproportionately disadvantages certain groups can give rise to discrimination claims, especially if decisions about withholding contractual sick pay or triggering capability procedures are not supported by objective justification. Employers should consider reasonable adjustments, including in relation to absence triggers or evidence requirements, where disability is in play.

Clear communication between HR, line managers and payroll is therefore critical. Everyone involved should understand the statutory SSP framework, the organisation’s contractual schemes and the need to treat employees consistently and lawfully. A joined-up approach reduces the risk of unlawful deduction claims, disputes over entitlement and allegations of discriminatory treatment.

Section C: Payslips & Pay Statements

Itemised payslips are a statutory requirement for UK employers and form a core part of pay transparency and payroll compliance. Payslips allow workers to understand how their pay has been calculated, which deductions have been made and what their net earnings are for each pay period. Failing to issue payslips, or issuing payslips that are incomplete or inaccurate, can expose employers to unlawful deduction claims and tribunal orders requiring payslips to be reissued or corrected.

The legal right to receive an itemised pay statement applies to both employees and workers. It also covers individuals on zero-hours arrangements and agency workers who are engaged and paid directly by the employer. Where an agency is responsible for engaging and paying the worker, it is the agency—not the end user—that must issue the payslip. Contractors and genuinely self-employed individuals do not have a statutory right to an itemised payslip, although some may receive statements under the terms of their commercial arrangements.

1. What a legally compliant payslip must include

Under the statutory rules, payslips must be provided on or before the date the worker is paid. They may be issued electronically or in paper form, but they must be accessible to the worker, including after employment ends. A compliant payslip must set out:

• Gross pay for the relevant pay period.
• The amount and purpose of each deduction.
• Net pay after deductions.
• Where pay varies by the number of hours worked, the number of hours for which the worker is being paid.

Employers must ensure that payslips reflect the true position regarding hours, earnings and deductions. Areas that commonly give rise to error include pension contributions, National Insurance, student loan deductions, salary sacrifice arrangements and adjustments for overtime or holiday pay. Relying solely on automated payroll outputs without appropriate checks can create inaccuracies that amount to unlawful deductions.

2. Formats, accessibility and retention

Electronic payslips are widely used, but employers must ensure they remain accessible to workers at all times. Password-protected systems should allow current and former workers to download or view historic payslips without unreasonable barriers. Failure to provide access may amount to a breach of statutory obligations, particularly where a worker requires payslip evidence to support a mortgage application, benefit claim or dispute resolution.

Payslips may be delivered in paper form if this is the employer’s standard method or where electronic access is not appropriate for a particular worker. Whatever the format, the employer must be able to demonstrate that payslips are issued consistently and on time.

Although there is no prescriptive statutory retention period specifically for payslips, employers typically retain them for at least six years to align with broader limitation periods for wage and tax-related claims.

3. Addressing errors, omissions and disputes

Where a worker raises a concern about a payslip, employers must investigate promptly. If an error is identified, the employer should correct the issue, adjust any underpayment or overpayment and issue an amended payslip as necessary. Taking swift corrective action can prevent minor issues from escalating into formal disputes or tribunal claims.

If a dispute arises, employment tribunals have limited powers in relation to payslip claims themselves. While they cannot award compensation purely for missing or inaccurate payslips, they can issue declarations and require employers to provide compliant statements. Where the payslip issue is connected to an unlawful deduction of wages claim, the tribunal may also consider financial losses associated with the incorrect payment.

4. Coordination between HR, managers and payroll

Accurate payslips depend on effective communication and coordination across the organisation. HR teams, line managers and payroll must ensure that changes to working hours, overtime, absence, bonuses, deductions and allowances are communicated accurately and in time for payroll processing. Inconsistent or late submission of information is a leading cause of payslip errors.

Employers should implement clear internal processes for approving pay-related changes, updating payroll instructions and validating payslip output. This helps reduce inconsistencies, supports transparency and ensures that workers are paid correctly and on time.

Section D: When Wages Are Not Paid

Timely and accurate payment of wages is a fundamental legal obligation. When wages are paid late, underpaid or withheld altogether, employers risk unlawful deduction claims, breach of contract allegations and potentially significant disruption to workforce relations. Administrative mistakes, system failures, unclear contractual terms or misunderstandings about entitlements are common causes of wage errors, but the legal position remains the same: workers must receive the full amount owed on the date payment is due.

Both employees and workers can bring statutory claims where wages have not been paid correctly. These claims may relate to unpaid basic pay, overtime, bonuses, commission, holiday pay or statutory payments such as SSP, provided the entitlement forms part of the individual’s contractual or statutory rights. Even a single incorrect payment can give rise to a valid claim, and repeated failures may increase legal exposure.

1. Employer responsibilities when wages are missing or incorrect

Where an error is identified—either by the employer or the worker—the employer should act promptly. Key steps typically include:

• Investigating the cause of the non-payment or underpayment.
• Calculating the precise shortfall, including adjustments to holiday pay or pension contributions where necessary.
• Making corrective payment as soon as possible rather than waiting for the next payroll cycle.
• Issuing an amended payslip that accurately reflects the corrected payment.

If the issue relates to a minimum wage breach, employers must also ensure that arrears are paid in line with HMRC enforcement policy. This generally requires repayment at the current NMW or NLW rate, which may exceed the historical rate in force at the time the underpayment originally occurred. Employers should also review internal systems to prevent a recurrence.

2. Contractual disputes, breach of contract and termination issues

More complex pay disputes may arise where contractual entitlements are unclear or where bonus and commission arrangements have been applied incorrectly. In such cases, employers must review the underlying contractual terms and ensure that performance criteria, eligibility rules and calculation methods have been applied appropriately.

When employment has ended, employees—but not workers—may bring breach of contract claims in the employment tribunal to recover unpaid wages or other sums owed under the contract. If the claim relates to unpaid sums during ongoing employment, the appropriate route is normally the civil courts, unless the matter falls within the scope of statutory wage protection rules.

Employers should be especially careful when withholding sums in the final pay period. Unless a deduction is authorised by statute, clearly stated in the contract, or supported by written consent, withholding pay may amount to an unlawful deduction even where the employer believes the worker owes money to the organisation.

3. Discrimination and equality considerations

Although wage disputes often arise from administrative issues, mistakes can sometimes reveal or contribute to equality risks. For example, if pay errors disproportionately affect a particular group—such as part-time workers, those returning from maternity leave or workers with disabilities—this may give rise to wider claims under the Equality Act 2010. Employers must ensure that decisions about pay, adjustments and corrections are made consistently and based on objective evidence rather than assumptions or subjective judgment.

Withholding pay for reasons linked to protected characteristics or statutory rights can also amount to victimisation or discrimination. Employers should therefore document decision-making thoroughly and provide clear, non-discriminatory explanations where disputes arise.

4. Systems, communication and preventing recurrence

Repeated wage errors often indicate wider issues with payroll systems, scheduling processes or communication between managers, HR and payroll. Employers should review:

• Time recording systems and verification processes.
• How changes to hours, rates or entitlements are communicated internally.
• Whether managers are trained to authorise and record overtime or variable hours correctly.
• Whether payroll has access to up-to-date contractual terms, policies and evidence.

Workers should also be encouraged to raise concerns early so that issues can be resolved quickly. Clear communication helps maintain trust and demonstrates that the employer is addressing the issue transparently and proactively. Employers may also consider providing guidance to employees on how to review payslips, how to report discrepancies and what to expect when an error is being investigated.

Section E: Deductions From Pay

UK employers may only make deductions from a worker’s pay in limited circumstances. Any deduction made outside these boundaries risks constituting an unlawful deduction under statutory wage protection rules. Even well-intentioned deductions can give rise to claims if they lack a valid statutory, contractual or consent-based foundation. Employers should therefore ensure that all deduction practices are transparent, specific and clearly authorised before implementation.

The key legal principle is that deductions from wages are lawful only if they fall into one of three categories:

• Deductions required or authorised by legislation, such as tax, National Insurance or court orders.
• Deductions authorised by a clear contractual term that the worker has been informed of.
• Deductions to which the worker has given their explicit, written consent.

1. Statutory and contractual deductions

Statutory deductions include PAYE income tax, National Insurance contributions, student loan repayments and deductions required by court orders or child maintenance arrangements. Employers must apply these correctly, ensuring payroll systems reflect the latest thresholds and rates.

Contractual deductions must be set out clearly in the employment contract or a document expressly referred to within it. Clauses must be specific and transparent. Vague or overly broad provisions are unlikely to be enforceable. Typical contractual deductions include recovery of season ticket loans, adjustment of overpayments or contributions toward benefits provided by the employer.

Where deductions relate to overpayments of wages, employers generally have the legal right to recover the sums without consent. However, recovery must still be reasonable and should not be carried out in a way that causes financial hardship or amounts to a breach of trust and confidence. Employers should communicate clearly, propose reasonable repayment schedules where appropriate and document the steps taken to ensure fairness.

2. Deductions requiring worker consent

Some deductions require explicit, written agreement from the worker, usually for specific, identifiable purposes. Examples include voluntary benefit schemes, training costs that the worker has agreed to repay under defined conditions or one-off deductions for agreed expenses or equipment purchases. Consent cannot be implied: it must be freely given and documented. The scope and purpose of the deduction must be clear at the point of consent.

Employers should also revisit consent periodically to ensure it remains appropriate, particularly for deductions that are ongoing or variable in amount. Where circumstances change, employers may need to obtain renewed consent or amend the underlying arrangement.

3. Interaction with minimum wage rules

The minimum wage rules place additional restrictions on deductions. Even where a deduction is lawful under contract or with consent, it may still breach minimum wage law if it reduces the worker’s average hourly pay below the applicable NMW or NLW rate in the relevant pay reference period.

Deductions or payments which are considered to be for the employer’s “own use or benefit” – such as required uniforms, tools, equipment, certain forms of travel between work locations or administrative charges – reduce pay for minimum wage purposes. If these costs bring average hourly pay below the legal threshold, the employer will have underpaid the minimum wage, regardless of the worker’s agreement. Employers must carefully assess whether proposed deductions fall into this category and monitor pay calculations accordingly.

4. Timing, communication and deductions on termination

Unless expressly agreed otherwise, deductions should be taken from the next available wage payment. Spreading deductions over multiple pay periods without agreement can create disputes, especially where the sums involved are significant. Employers should communicate clearly with workers about why a deduction is being made, how much will be deducted and when the deduction will appear on the payslip.

When employment ends, any deductions from final pay must meet the same legal tests as deductions made during employment. Employers must ensure that:

• The deduction is authorised by statute, contract or written consent.
• The deduction does not breach minimum wage rules for the final pay period, particularly where the deduction relates to items for the employer’s benefit.
• The contract allows for the deduction to be made after termination if the purpose relates to outstanding loans, equipment or other sums owed.

Unlawful deductions during the final pay period are a common trigger for tribunal claims. Employers should therefore pay particular attention to deductions related to unreturned equipment, advances or training costs, ensuring any recovery clauses are legally sound, proportionate and clearly communicated at the outset of employment.

Section F: Final Pay When Employment Ends

When employment ends, employers must ensure that the final payment issued to the departing worker is complete, accurate and paid on time. Final pay is subject to increased scrutiny because it often includes several different elements, such as unpaid basic wages, accrued holiday pay, notice pay, overtime, commission, bonuses and authorised deductions. Any omission or miscalculation can lead to unlawful deduction claims, breach of contract allegations or strained post-employment relations.

Employers should adopt a structured approach to final pay calculations to minimise the risk of errors and disputes. This requires reviewing contractual terms, statutory entitlements, time records, outstanding expenses, loans or advances and any other elements of the worker’s pay that may require adjustment before termination.

1. Components of final pay

Final pay typically includes:

• Outstanding basic pay up to the last day of employment.
• Overtime, commission or bonuses already earned under the relevant scheme rules.
• Untaken statutory holiday accrued up to the termination date.
• Contractual notice pay, whether worked or paid in lieu.

Where the employee works their notice period, the employer must pay for all hours worked up to the termination date. Where the employer chooses to make a payment in lieu of notice (PILON), the payment must reflect the worker’s full entitlement under the contract or the statutory minimum notice period, whichever is higher.

If a PILON clause is not included in the contract, making a payment in lieu may still be lawful, but it may amount to a breach of contract that brings restrictive covenants into question. Employers should therefore review contracts before making decisions about notice arrangements.

2. Holiday pay calculations on termination

Holiday pay is one of the most common sources of error during final pay processing. Workers are entitled to payment for all statutory annual leave accrued but not taken by the termination date. The method for calculating holiday pay depends on whether the worker has normal working hours, irregular hours or part-year working patterns.

For workers with irregular hours or part-year patterns, statutory rules require the use of a 52-week reference period (or a shorter period where 52 paid weeks are not available) to calculate average pay. This may include regular overtime, commission and other earnings that form part of the worker’s normal remuneration.

For workers with normal working hours that do not vary, holiday pay is generally based on contractual pay unless other regular payments form part of normal remuneration under case law. Employers must therefore review the worker’s pay history and contractual arrangements to ensure accurate calculation.

3. Deductions from final pay

Deductions from final pay must meet the same legal standards as deductions made during employment. This means that deductions must be:

• Authorised by statute,
• Clearly set out in the employment contract, or
• Supported by the worker’s explicit, written consent.

Deductions commonly arise on termination where the worker owes money for outstanding loans, salary advances or the cost of unreturned property. Employers must ensure that any recovery clause is sufficiently specific and that the deduction does not reduce pay below the applicable NMW or NLW for the final pay reference period where the deduction relates to items for the employer’s own benefit.

Employers should not withhold final pay to compel the return of property unless the contract expressly allows this. Even then, deductions must be reasonable and clearly linked to the circumstances outlined in the contractual clause.

4. Timing, payslips and dispute prevention

Final pay should normally be made on the worker’s usual payday unless the contract specifies an alternative arrangement. Delays can increase the risk of disputes, cause hardship for the worker and escalate the likelihood of legal claims. Employers must also issue an itemised payslip with the final payment, showing all earnings and deductions clearly.

Where disputes arise regarding bonus eligibility, commission, holiday pay, repayment of training costs or other contractual entitlements, employers should review the relevant contractual terms, scheme documentation and records of performance or attendance. Clear documentation helps avoid or resolve disputes and positions the employer to justify decisions if challenged.

Employees may bring breach of contract claims in an employment tribunal after termination to recover unpaid sums, whereas workers who are not employees may need to pursue claims through the civil courts unless their complaint falls within unlawful deduction rules. Employers should therefore ensure that the full legal context is understood before taking final pay decisions.

Section G: Pay for Working Extra Hours

UK employers must ensure that workers are paid correctly for additional hours worked beyond their normal contractual arrangements. This area is particularly sensitive because it intersects with contractual terms, working time rules and minimum wage obligations. Errors frequently arise where extra hours are not recorded accurately, overtime arrangements are informal or managers misunderstand how pay and rest requirements interact. Clear processes, accurate record keeping and legally compliant policies are essential to avoid disputes and ensure proper remuneration.

1. Contractual overtime arrangements

The starting point for determining how extra hours must be paid is the employment contract. Some contracts contain explicit overtime provisions setting out:

• Whether overtime must be authorised in advance,
• The rate of pay for overtime (e.g., time and a half),
• Eligibility criteria, and
• Whether overtime is compulsory or voluntary.

Other contracts may be silent on overtime. In these cases, workers are generally entitled to receive their normal hourly rate for additional hours worked unless a different arrangement can be demonstrated through custom and practice. For salaried-hours workers, entitlement depends on whether the extra hours exceed the basic hours for which the salary is intended to compensate. Employers must ensure that arrangements are both lawful and clearly communicated to avoid misunderstandings.

2. Minimum wage considerations for extra hours

Minimum wage compliance is a critical aspect of overtime management. Even where a worker receives a salary rather than an hourly rate, the employer must ensure that the worker’s total pay for the pay reference period, when divided by the actual hours worked—including overtime—does not fall below the applicable NMW or NLW rate.

This creates a significant risk where employers expect staff to work regular or substantial additional hours without separate remuneration. If those extra hours reduce the worker’s average hourly pay below the statutory threshold, the employer will have underpaid the minimum wage. HMRC may require arrears to be repaid at the current NMW or NLW rate and may impose penalties.

Employers should undertake periodic checks to ensure that salaried staff working variable or extended hours remain compliant with minimum wage rules. This is particularly important in sectors with fluctuating workloads, unpaid overtime cultures or long-hours expectations.

3. Working Time Regulations: rest, limits and on-call time

Extra hours must also comply with the Working Time Regulations (WTR). The Regulations set out minimum requirements for rest breaks, daily rest, weekly rest and limits on weekly working hours. Key rules include:

• A minimum 20-minute uninterrupted rest break for shifts longer than six hours,
• At least 11 consecutive hours’ rest in each 24-hour period,
• At least one 24-hour uninterrupted rest period each week (or 48 hours every two weeks), and
• A 48-hour average weekly working limit unless a valid opt-out is signed.

Any opt-out from the 48-hour average weekly limit must be voluntary, in writing, and capable of being withdrawn at any time. Employers must not pressurise workers to sign opt-outs for convenience.

Determining whether additional time counts as working time can be complex. Time spent on call may count as working time where the worker is required to remain at a specified location or is subject to significant restrictions. Interruptions during rest breaks may also convert part of that time into working time. Employers should consider these factors carefully when assessing overtime and rest entitlements.

4. Recording and approving extra hours

Clear and reliable time recording is essential for managing extra hours lawfully. Employers should implement systems and policies that enable:

• Accurate recording of all hours worked, including breaks and on-call periods where appropriate,
• Managerial approval of overtime before it is worked, unless impracticable,
• Regular reconciliation of time records with payroll output, and
• Transparent communication with workers about what constitutes authorised overtime.

Informal arrangements—such as simply “staying late until the work is done”—create significant legal risk if not captured through proper timekeeping. Employers should train managers to recognise and record additional hours even where they are not explicitly authorised in advance, as workers remain legally entitled to be paid for the time actually worked.

5. Time off in lieu (TOIL) arrangements

Instead of paying overtime, some employers operate Time Off In Lieu (TOIL) schemes. Under a TOIL arrangement, workers take paid time off in proportion to the additional hours worked. For TOIL to be lawful and effective:

• The arrangement must be clearly explained in the contract or policy,
• The worker must agree to TOIL before the additional hours are worked,
• TOIL must be recorded accurately, and
• Time off must be taken within a reasonable period.

Importantly, TOIL must never result in the worker receiving less than the minimum wage for the relevant pay reference period. Employers must ensure that TOIL arrangements do not inadvertently mask underpayments or create losses for workers with variable hours.

By establishing transparent rules around authorising, recording and compensating extra hours, employers can significantly reduce the risk of disputes and legal breaches. A consistent, well-communicated overtime and TOIL framework helps maintain compliance, preserve morale and reinforce fair working practices.

Section H: Pay for Mandatory Training

Mandatory training is legally treated as working time for pay purposes. If an employer requires a worker to undertake training—whether for induction, compliance, safety, skills development or to maintain professional competency—the time spent completing that training must be paid. This applies regardless of whether the training takes place during normal working hours, outside usual shifts or on a day the worker is not ordinarily scheduled to work.

Failure to pay for mandatory training is a common cause of minimum wage breaches, particularly where training is completed online or outside normal working patterns. Employers must therefore ensure that mandatory training requirements are communicated clearly and that payroll systems reflect all training hours appropriately.

1. Mandatory versus voluntary training

The key legal distinction is whether the training is genuinely optional or a requirement of the job. Training will generally be considered mandatory where:

• The employer requires attendance or completion as a condition of employment, continued work or performance standards.
• The training is needed to perform the role safely or competently.
• The training is required under regulatory, licensing or accreditation rules.
• The employer later relies on the training to assess performance, suitability for the role or compliance.

Even if a worker volunteers for a development opportunity, if the employer requires the training for the role, it will usually be treated as mandatory and must be paid. Conversely, where training is genuinely optional, offers no direct advantage to the employer and is not required for continued employment, employers may not be required to pay for it—but the distinction must be transparent.

2. Minimum wage implications

Time spent on mandatory training always counts as working time for minimum wage purposes. Employers must therefore ensure that payment for training is included when determining whether the worker’s pay meets or exceeds the applicable NMW or NLW rate for the relevant pay reference period.

If a worker is required to complete unpaid training—such as online modules or induction activities—outside their normal working hours, the employer may inadvertently breach minimum wage law. This risk is particularly acute for apprentices, junior staff, part-time workers and those on irregular hours.

3. Recording training time and completion expectations

Accurate recording of training time is essential. Employers should maintain clear records of:

• The date, duration and type of training completed,
• Whether the training was completed in person or online,
• Whether the worker was required to complete the training within work time or outside it, and
• The expected time required to complete any self-paced e-learning.

Where training is asynchronous—for example, e-learning modules that can be completed at any time—the employer should specify the expected completion time and pay workers accordingly. Instructing workers to complete mandatory e-learning “in their own time” without pay is a common compliance failure.

4. Expenses and off-site training

Where workers incur expenses to attend mandatory training—such as travel, accommodation or materials—the employer must ensure that reimbursements or deductions do not reduce pay below the minimum wage for the relevant period. Expenses necessary for the performance of training generally count as costs for the employer’s benefit and thus reduce pay for minimum wage calculations unless fully reimbursed.

If training is held off-site or outside normal working patterns, employers should communicate arrangements clearly, including pay entitlements, travel arrangements, rest breaks and expectations around attendance.

5. Communication, fairness and consistency

Clear communication about what training is mandatory, how it will be paid and when it must be completed is crucial to maintaining transparency and avoiding disputes. Employers must also apply rules consistently to avoid allegations of unfair treatment or indirect discrimination, particularly where training expectations disproportionately affect certain groups.

Providing accessible policies, ensuring that managers understand pay obligations for training and maintaining detailed records all contribute to a robust compliance framework. By recognising training as working time and paying workers accordingly, employers support both legal compliance and workforce development.

Section I: Pay Rises

Pay rises form an important part of workforce management, reward strategy and legal compliance. Whether driven by contractual commitments, performance frameworks, market conditions or statutory minimum wage changes, employers must implement pay increases lawfully, transparently and consistently. Poorly managed pay rise processes can result in grievances, discrimination allegations or unlawful deduction claims.

A structured approach allows employers to manage pay reviews fairly and to ensure any changes are clearly communicated and reflected in payroll without delay.

1. Contractual and discretionary pay rises

Some employment contracts include explicit provisions for annual reviews or guaranteed pay rises. Where a contractual pay increase is promised—such as a set annual uplift—the employer must honour it or risk breaching the contract.

Other contracts simply state that pay “will be reviewed” periodically. In these cases, the employer must still carry out a genuine review, but is not obliged to award an increase unless the contract specifies otherwise. However, employers should ensure that reviews are meaningful, evidence-based and properly documented to avoid allegations of bad faith or discriminatory treatment.

Where pay rises are discretionary, employers should apply clear, objective criteria and ensure decisions are consistent across comparable groups. Failing to do so can create risks under the Equality Act 2010, particularly where part-time workers, those returning from maternity leave or workers with disabilities receive disproportionately fewer increases.

2. Statutory minimum wage increases

Regardless of any contractual arrangements, employers must ensure that workers’ pay always meets or exceeds the applicable National Minimum Wage or National Living Wage. Rates typically increase annually, often in April, and employers must ensure that payroll systems are updated in time to avoid underpayment.

Where a pay rise is required to meet statutory minimum wage obligations, the employer must implement the new rate from the day the statutory change takes effect. Failure to do so can immediately place the employer in breach of NMW law and expose the organisation to arrears, penalties and enforcement action.

3. Equality, fairness and documentation

Decisions about pay must comply with equality legislation. Employers must ensure that pay rises are not influenced by protected characteristics such as age, sex, disability, race, pregnancy or maternity status. Transparent criteria—such as performance metrics, skills, market benchmarks or business needs—are critical to demonstrating fair and lawful decision-making.

Documenting pay review outcomes, the reasons for decisions and any supporting evidence helps employers defend against claims and supports consistent future decision-making. Employers should maintain a clear audit trail and ensure that line managers understand how to apply criteria objectively.

4. Payroll updates and communication

Once a pay rise has been agreed, employers must update payroll systems promptly so that the increased rate is reflected in the next pay period. Delays in implementation may result in underpayments and could give rise to unlawful deduction claims.

Employers must also comply with the requirement under the Employment Rights Act to provide written notification of any contractual change—including pay—within one month. Written confirmation should set out the new rate of pay, the date it takes effect and any changes to related benefits or entitlements.

Clear communication with workers about pay rise decisions, timelines and effective dates is essential for transparency and trust. Employers should provide feedback where relevant and ensure that employees understand how the review process operates.

Well-managed pay rise processes support legal compliance, enhance employee engagement and strengthen the overall employment relationship. By applying objective criteria, updating payroll promptly and maintaining clear documentation, employers can ensure consistency and minimise the risk of disputes.

Section J: Bonuses

Bonuses play a significant role in performance management, motivation and overall remuneration. However, they are also a common source of legal disputes because entitlement often depends on the precise wording of contracts or bonus scheme rules. Employers must distinguish clearly between contractual and discretionary schemes, apply eligibility criteria consistently and ensure calculations are transparent. Failure to do so may result in unlawful deduction claims, breach of contract allegations or discrimination risks.

A well-structured bonus framework defines eligibility, timing, performance measures and payment rules clearly, reducing ambiguity and ensuring that decisions withstand scrutiny.

1. Contractual bonuses

A bonus is contractual where the employment contract or bonus scheme states that the worker is entitled to receive a bonus if certain conditions are met. Once those conditions are satisfied, the employer must pay the bonus in full and on time. Failure to do so may amount to an unlawful deduction of wages or breach of contract.

Contractual bonus schemes should specify:

• The performance measures or targets that trigger entitlement,
• The calculation method,
• Timing of payments,
• Whether any clawback provisions apply, and
• Whether sickness, maternity leave or other absences affect entitlement.

Ambiguity in contractual schemes is interpreted against the employer, particularly where the wording is unclear or inconsistent with past practice. Employers should therefore review scheme documents regularly to ensure accuracy and clarity.

2. Discretionary bonuses

Discretionary bonuses allow the employer to decide whether to award a bonus, in what amount and based on which factors. Even where broad discretion is granted, it must be exercised rationally, consistently and in good faith. Decisions must be supported by evidence and must not be discriminatory or arbitrary.

A discretionary bonus may become an implied contractual entitlement if it is paid regularly over a significant period and workers reasonably expect it. Employers should therefore be cautious about establishing practices that could later be interpreted as contractual.

Where discretionary bonuses are paid frequently, tribunals may determine that they form part of an employee’s “normal remuneration”, which may have implications for holiday pay calculations under established case law.

3. Bonus eligibility and end-of-employment issues

Bonus disputes commonly arise when employment ends before the bonus payment date. Whether a departing worker is entitled to a payment depends on the scheme rules. Schemes may state that the worker must:

• Still be employed on the bonus payment date,
• Have been employed throughout a specified qualifying period, or
• Have met certain performance or attendance conditions.

If the scheme is silent or ambiguous, tribunals often interpret provisions in favour of the worker. Clear wording is therefore essential to avoid uncertainty about entitlement. Employers should also address how long-term absences, such as maternity leave or disability-related absence, interact with bonus eligibility, ensuring compliance with equality laws.

4. Clawback and adjustment mechanisms

Clawback provisions allow employers to recover bonus payments in defined circumstances, such as misconduct, compliance failures or customer cancellations. However, clawback clauses must be reasonable, proportionate and clearly communicated. Overly broad or punitive clauses may be unenforceable.

Clawback rules should specify:

• The circumstances in which repayment is required,
• The method for calculating the sum to be recovered,
• The timeframe for repayment, and
• Whether repayment may be deducted from wages (where lawful), or must be repaid separately.

5. Payroll treatment, tax and holiday pay considerations

Bonus payments are subject to tax and National Insurance in the same way as ordinary wages. Employers must ensure correct payroll treatment, especially where bonuses are non-cash or delivered through vouchers or shares, as these may require additional reporting.

Where bonuses form part of normal remuneration, they may need to be included in holiday pay calculations. Case law requires holiday pay to reflect normal earnings rather than basic pay alone, meaning that regular or intrinsic bonuses may increase the holiday pay entitlement. Employers should therefore ensure that payroll systems apply the correct calculation method.

Robust documentation, transparent communication and consistent application of scheme rules are essential to managing bonus arrangements lawfully. By clearly distinguishing between contractual and discretionary elements and ensuring calculations are accurate, employers can minimise legal risk and maintain trust in performance-based reward structures.

Section K: Commission

Commission is a core component of pay in many sales, service and revenue-generating roles. Because commission arrangements vary significantly between organisations, disputes often arise from unclear scheme wording, inconsistent application or misunderstanding of when commission is “earned” versus when it becomes “payable”. Employers must therefore ensure that all commission arrangements are drafted with precision, applied consistently and aligned with statutory requirements, including minimum wage and holiday pay rules.

A well-designed commission scheme sets out performance measures, calculation rules, eligibility criteria and payment timing clearly, reducing ambiguity and supporting lawful and transparent pay practices.

1. Defining entitlement: earned vs payable

A critical legal distinction in commission schemes is the point at which commission is considered “earned” as opposed to when it is actually paid. Schemes must clearly define:

• The event that triggers the earning of commission (e.g., sale completed, contract signed, revenue received),
• Any conditions that must be satisfied before payment is made (e.g., customer payment, completion of probation),
• Whether the worker must still be employed on the payment date, and
• Whether commission can be clawed back if a sale is cancelled or refunded.

Ambiguous wording frequently leads to disputes. Where a scheme does not expressly require employment on the payment date, tribunals often interpret the ambiguity in favour of the worker. Employers should therefore review scheme documentation carefully to ensure precision and enforceability.

2. Commission and holiday pay

Where commission is sufficiently regular, predictable or intrinsically linked to the role, it may form part of “normal remuneration” and must be included in statutory holiday pay calculations. Courts have ruled that holiday pay should reflect average earnings, not just basic salary. This means that workers who regularly earn commission should receive holiday pay that reflects those earnings.

Employers must ensure that payroll systems use the correct reference period—normally 52 paid weeks—to calculate holiday pay where commission forms part of normal remuneration. Failure to do so may result in unlawful deduction claims and arrears liabilities extending back over multiple holiday years, subject to statutory limits.

3. Minimum wage compliance

Commission cannot be used to “top up” pay retrospectively to meet the National Minimum Wage or National Living Wage. Even where a worker’s commission earnings are expected to be significant, the employer must ensure that the worker receives at least the applicable minimum wage for each pay reference period based solely on the pay actually received in that period.

This creates compliance risk where workers have low basic salaries or experience months with reduced commission. Employers should monitor pay levels carefully, especially for new starters, workers in low-sales periods or those on part-time hours.

4. Commission on termination of employment

Commission disputes often arise when employment ends. Key questions include:

• Has the worker already earned the commission under the scheme rules?
• Does the scheme require the worker to be employed on the date of payment?
• Should payments be pro-rated?
• Does the contract allow for commission on future or pipeline sales?

Where scheme wording is unclear, tribunals may favour interpretations that support the worker’s right to receive commission already earned. Employers should therefore include express provisions dealing with termination, including the status of pending deals, recurring revenue, partially completed work and clawback situations.

5. Record keeping, calculation accuracy and clawbacks

Comprehensive documentation is essential. Employers should keep clear records of:

• Sales data and performance metrics,
• Commission calculations and approvals,
• Adjustments, cancellations and refunds, and
• Any clawbacks applied under the scheme.

Clawback clauses must be proportionate, reasonable and clearly worded. A clause that operates as a penalty or is overly broad may be unenforceable. Employers should also ensure that clawbacks do not reduce pay below the minimum wage for the relevant period where the deduction relates to the employer’s own benefit.

By maintaining transparent, well-drafted commission schemes and ensuring compliance with minimum wage, holiday pay and termination rules, employers can significantly reduce the risk of costly disputes. Clear communication and consistent administration further strengthen trust and support fair performance-based pay structures.

Section L: Expenses

Expenses arise where workers incur costs in the performance of their duties. Although employers are not legally required to reimburse every type of work-related expense, they are required to ensure that expense practices do not result in unlawful deductions, minimum wage breaches or inconsistent treatment of workers. A clear, well-managed expenses framework reduces financial risk and supports fairness across the workforce.

Expenses must be handled in a way that is transparent, lawful and consistent with contractual terms, tax rules and minimum wage legislation. Employers should set out which expenses will be reimbursed, the process for claiming them and how reimbursements will be treated through payroll.

1. Expense policies and contractual clarity

A written expenses policy is essential. It should specify:

• Which expenses are reimbursable (e.g., business travel, accommodation, subsistence, training-related costs),
• Evidence requirements (e.g., receipts, mileage logs),
• Approval processes and spending limits,
• Non-reimbursable items (e.g., ordinary commuting), and
• Timeframes for submitting claims.

Travel between home and a regular workplace is normally not a business expense for tax purposes, meaning reimbursement is taxable if provided. By contrast, travel between different work locations or temporary workplaces will usually qualify for reimbursement without creating a tax liability.

Employers must ensure that policies are regularly reviewed and communicated clearly so that workers understand entitlement and processes.

2. Interaction with minimum wage rules

Expense practices must comply with the National Minimum Wage legislation. If a worker incurs expenses that are necessary for their role and those costs are not reimbursed, they may count as expenses “for the employer’s own benefit”. In such cases, the expenses reduce pay for minimum wage purposes.

This means that unreimbursed costs—such as required travel between assignments, uniforms, equipment or training-related materials—can cause a minimum wage breach even where the worker’s headline rate appears compliant. Employers must therefore assess whether reimbursement is required to maintain minimum wage compliance and must implement prompt repayment processes where appropriate.

3. Tax treatment and payroll processing

Expenses must be processed in line with HMRC rules. Many expenses are non-taxable when incurred wholly, exclusively and necessarily for work. However, employers must ensure that:

• Claims are supported by appropriate evidence,
• Flat-rate allowances comply with HMRC requirements,
• Taxable expenses are processed through payroll, and
• Expense payments are not used to disguise wages.

Incorrect classification of expenses can create tax liabilities for both the employer and worker. Employers should work closely with payroll and finance teams to ensure accuracy and compliance.

4. Disputes, fairness and discrimination considerations

Expense disputes commonly arise where policies are unclear, inconsistently applied or not adapted to modern working arrangements such as hybrid or remote work. Employers should ensure that managers apply expense rules fairly and consistently to avoid claims of unfair treatment or indirect discrimination.

Clear guidance should be provided on emerging areas such as:

• Homeworking equipment and allowances,
• Travel to multiple workplaces,
• Use of personal vehicles or phones for business purposes, and
• Expenses during training or off-site meetings.

Where employers deduct sums from wages to recover expense advances, company card misuse or incorrect claims, these deductions must comply with the statutory rules: they must be authorised by statute, clearly set out in the contract or supported by the worker’s written consent. Employers must also ensure that such deductions do not reduce pay below the minimum wage where the deduction relates to costs for the employer’s benefit.

By implementing clear policies, applying rules consistently and ensuring that expense practices align with tax law and minimum wage requirements, employers can significantly reduce the risk of disputes and maintain confidence in the fairness of their reimbursement processes.

Section M: Tips & Service Charges

Tips, gratuities and service charges are governed by a dedicated statutory framework that imposes clear duties on UK employers. The Employment (Allocation of Tips) Act 2023 requires employers to pass on all qualifying tips to workers in full, ensure that allocation is fair and transparent, and comply with a statutory Code of Practice. The legislation reflects a sector-wide move toward greater transparency in tipping practices, particularly in hospitality, leisure and service industries.

The Act applies to any tip, gratuity or service charge over which the employer exercises control or significant influence. This includes card payments, app-based tips and discretionary service charges. The overarching principle is that employers must not retain any portion of tips for themselves, other than permitted statutory deductions such as tax.

1. Passing on qualifying tips in full

Employers must ensure that all qualifying tips are distributed to workers without deductions. Deductions for administrative costs, card processing fees, breakages, walkouts or similar losses are prohibited. Tips belong to workers, not to the employer, and must be paid out accordingly.

Where tips are collected centrally—for example, through a card machine—the employer must pass them on to workers no later than the end of the month following the month in which the tip was received. Employers must adopt a consistent process for calculating distribution periods and ensuring payments are made on time.

2. Fair allocation and the statutory Code of Practice

The Act requires that tips be allocated fairly and transparently. The statutory Code of Practice provides detailed guidance on what constitutes “fair” distribution. Although employers may depart from the Code in limited circumstances, any departure must be objectively justified and evidence-based.

The Code emphasises factors such as:

• Hours worked,
• Role and level of responsibility,
• Customer-facing contributions, and
• Team-based service delivery.

Employers must consult with workers or representatives when establishing or revising tipping policies. Any allocation method must be clearly documented, consistently applied and capable of explanation to workers and regulators.

3. Troncs and independent tip distribution

Many employers use a tronc system to distribute tips. A tronc is an arrangement whereby tips are collected into a central pool and distributed by a tronc operator (or “troncmaster”), who must act independently from the employer when deciding allocation.

While tronc operators have discretion over distribution, employers still have legal obligations, including:

• Ensuring the tronc complies with statutory requirements,
• Maintaining accurate records of all tips received and distributed,
• Providing information to workers upon request, and
• Ensuring payments are made within statutory deadlines.

Employers must not influence the distribution decisions of the tronc operator, as doing so may invalidate the independence of the system and expose the employer to liability.

4. Record keeping and worker rights to information

Employers must keep detailed records of tips received and distributed for at least three years. Records must show how tips were collected, the allocation method used and the specific amounts paid to each worker.

Workers have the right to request information about tipping records and allocation methods. Employers must respond within the statutory timeframe—usually four weeks. Failure to provide the required information may lead to tribunal claims and compensation orders.

5. Minimum wage and tax considerations

Tips do not count toward National Minimum Wage or National Living Wage calculations. Employers cannot rely on tips to meet minimum wage obligations, even if tips form a substantial part of a worker’s income.

Tax treatment depends on how tips are distributed:

• If the employer controls distribution, PAYE must be operated on tip payments.
• If an independent tronc operates the distribution, the troncmaster is responsible for tax administration.
• Cash tips given directly by customers to workers are taxable income, but the responsibility for reporting rests with the worker.

Employers must ensure that payroll, HR and finance teams understand the tax distinctions and apply the correct processes.

By complying with the Tipping Act 2023, maintaining transparent policies and ensuring robust record keeping, employers can reduce the risk of disputes, meet statutory obligations and support fairness for workers in customer-facing roles. Clear communication and consistent application of tipping rules reinforce trust and strengthen organisational culture.

Section N: Workplace Pensions

Workplace pensions are a central component of UK employment regulation. Under the automatic enrolment regime established by the Pensions Act 2008, employers must assess their workforce, enrol eligible workers into a qualifying pension scheme, make statutory minimum contributions and comply with extensive ongoing duties monitored by The Pensions Regulator. Failure to meet these obligations can result in substantial fines, enforcement notices and reputational damage.

Employers must maintain accurate assessments, apply correct contribution calculations and provide clear statutory information to workers. Effective coordination between HR, payroll and pension administrators is critical to ensuring full compliance.

1. Identifying eligible, non-eligible and entitled workers

Automatic enrolment duties apply to different categories of workers:

• Eligible jobholders — aged between 22 and State Pension Age and earning above the annual earnings trigger. These workers must be automatically enrolled.
• Non-eligible jobholders — who earn below the trigger or fall outside the eligible age band. These workers may opt in, and employers must contribute if they do.
• Entitled workers — who may join the pension scheme voluntarily. Employers are not required to contribute for this group.

Employers must assess all workers at the point automatic enrolment duties apply and re-assess them regularly, particularly where earnings fluctuate or age thresholds are crossed mid-year. Employers must issue statutory written communications to workers explaining their rights, enrolment status and contribution levels.

2. Employer and worker contributions

Employers must contribute at least the statutory minimum percentage based on qualifying earnings. Qualifying earnings include salary, wages, overtime, bonuses and certain other earnings within a prescribed band. These thresholds are reviewed annually, and payroll must be updated accordingly.

Workers must also contribute a statutory minimum amount unless they opt out. Contributions must be deducted correctly and paid into the pension scheme promptly. Errors—such as failing to assess the correct earnings band, missing contribution periods or miscalculating percentage rates—may create arrears that the employer must correct at its own cost.

Where an employer uses an alternative scheme structure with higher or differently calculated contributions, they must ensure that the scheme meets the definition of a qualifying pension scheme under automatic enrolment rules.

3. Opt-outs, refunds and unlawful inducements

Workers have a statutory right to opt out of the pension scheme within a prescribed period. If a worker opts out validly, the employer must refund both employer and employee contributions within one month.

It is unlawful for employers to encourage, pressure or incentivise workers to opt out or cease membership. Such behaviour—known as an “unlawful inducement”—can result in enforcement action and fines. Communications about pensions must therefore be neutral, factual and non-directive.

4. Re-enrolment every three years

Every three years, employers must re-assess their workforce and automatically re-enrol eligible jobholders who previously opted out. Employers must also submit a re-declaration of compliance to The Pensions Regulator confirming that their duties have been met.

Failure to complete re-enrolment or re-declaration obligations can lead to penalty notices, escalating fines and regulatory intervention. Employers should maintain clear calendars and processes to ensure deadlines are met.

5. Record keeping and compliance oversight

Automatic enrolment requires comprehensive record keeping, including:

• Worker assessments and categorisation,
• Enrolment notices and statutory information letters,
• Contribution schedules and payments,
• Opt-out and opt-in requests,
• Re-enrolment activities and re-declarations, and
• Evidence of qualifying scheme certification.

Records must be kept for prescribed periods and made available to The Pensions Regulator upon request. Employers should implement internal audits to monitor compliance and prevent errors from becoming systemic breaches.

6. Pension considerations at termination of employment

When employment ends, employers must ensure that pension contributions are calculated correctly up to the worker’s final day. Payroll must deduct and remit both employer and worker contributions in line with qualifying earnings for the final pay period.

Employers should also issue information about the worker’s pension rights, such as how to access or transfer their pension pot. Where salary sacrifice arrangements are in place, employers must ensure that contributions do not reduce cash earnings below the National Minimum Wage or National Living Wage at any point.

Robust pension administration, timely communications and ongoing compliance checks help employers meet their statutory obligations and avoid regulatory action. Clear processes and cross-department coordination ensure that workers receive the pension rights they are entitled to under UK law.

FAQs

1. What should an employer do if they realise a worker has been underpaid?
The employer must investigate the issue immediately, calculate the full shortfall and correct the payment without waiting for the next payroll cycle wherever possible. An amended payslip should be issued, and internal processes reviewed to prevent recurrence. If the underpayment breaches minimum wage law, arrears must be repaid at the current statutory rate. Failure to rectify the issue promptly may give rise to unlawful deduction or breach of contract claims.

2. Do all workers have the right to an itemised payslip?
Yes. All employees and workers have a statutory right to receive an itemised payslip showing gross pay, deductions, net pay and variable hours (where relevant). Agency workers paid by an employment agency receive payslips from the agency. Only genuinely self-employed individuals fall outside this requirement.

3. Can an employer deduct money for uniforms, equipment or training costs?
Deductions are lawful only if they are required by law, clearly authorised by the employment contract or supported by the worker’s written consent. Even where lawful, such deductions may reduce pay for minimum wage purposes where the cost is for the employer’s benefit. Employers must therefore ensure that workers still receive at least the statutory minimum wage after deductions are applied.

4. Is an employer required to pay for mandatory training completed outside normal hours?
Yes. Mandatory training counts as working time and must be paid. This includes training completed on non-working days or outside usual shift patterns. Unpaid mandatory training is a common cause of minimum wage breaches and unlawful deduction claims.

5. How should bonuses and commission be treated for holiday pay?
Where bonuses or commission form part of a worker’s “normal remuneration” and occur regularly enough to be predictable, these payments must be reflected in holiday pay calculations. Employers must use the appropriate statutory reference period, usually 52 paid weeks, when determining average earnings for holiday pay.

6. What happens if employment ends before a bonus or commission is paid?
Entitlement depends on the wording of the bonus or commission scheme. Some schemes require the worker to be employed on the payment date; others entitle the worker to payment once the bonus or commission is earned. If the scheme wording is unclear or ambiguous, tribunals may interpret it in favour of the worker.

7. Must employers reimburse all expenses?
No. Employers must reimburse expenses only where required by contract or policy. However, they must not impose expense practices or unreimbursed costs that reduce pay below minimum wage or amount to an unlawful deduction. Costs incurred for the employer’s benefit generally must be reimbursed promptly to remain compliant.

8. Do tips count towards the minimum wage?
No. Tips, gratuities and service charges cannot be used to meet National Minimum Wage or National Living Wage obligations. Employers must ensure basic pay meets statutory minimums regardless of tip income.

9. What pension duties apply to small employers?
All employers, regardless of size, must comply with automatic enrolment duties. This includes assessing the workforce, enrolling eligible workers, making minimum contributions, managing opt-outs and completing re-enrolment every three years.

10. Can workers bring claims for late or missing wage payments?
Yes. Workers may bring unlawful deduction claims where wages are withheld, underpaid or delayed. Employees may also bring breach of contract claims after employment ends. Persistent failures may even give rise to constructive dismissal claims in serious cases.

Conclusion

Ensuring lawful, accurate and transparent pay practices is one of the most fundamental responsibilities for employers under UK employment law. Workers must receive correct pay on time, supported by clear payslips, compliant statutory entitlements and fair treatment across overtime, bonuses, commission, expenses and pensions. Employers must also understand the distinctions between employees and workers, as entitlement varies across different areas of pay legislation.

Effective pay compliance requires robust systems, reliable record keeping and consistent application of policies. Employers must ensure that:

• Minimum wage rates are monitored and applied correctly,
• Sick pay, holiday pay and other statutory payments are calculated according to legal requirements,
• Deductions are lawful and transparent,
• Overtime, mandatory training and additional hours are recorded and paid properly,
• Bonuses and commission reflect contractual and statutory obligations, and
• Pension duties are met through accurate assessment and contribution processes.

Clear communication with workers reduces misunderstandings and helps maintain trust. Workers should understand how their pay is calculated, what deductions may apply, how incentive schemes operate and what to expect upon termination of employment. A well-managed payroll framework supports compliance, reduces disputes and reinforces organisational stability.

Ultimately, strong pay governance benefits both the organisation and its workforce. Employers who invest in compliant, well-structured pay systems minimise legal risk, enhance employee engagement and demonstrate a commitment to fairness and transparency across the employment relationship.

Glossary

Useful Links

Author

Gill Laing

Gill Laing is a qualified Legal Researcher & Analyst with niche specialisms in Law, Tax, Human Resources, Immigration & Employment Law.

Gill is a Multiple Business Owner and the Managing Director of Prof Services - a Marketing & Content Agency for the Professional Services Sector.

• Gill Laing

  UK ILR Earned Settlement Consultation Closes: HR Update
• Gill Laing

  Salary Sacrifice Pensions Contributions: 2029 NIC Cap Impact
• Gill Laing

  How UK Visa Systems Affect Hiring
• Gill Laing

  Employee Experience 2026: Development, Engagement & Performance