When Regular Overtime Becomes Contractual

Questions about when regular overtime becomes contractual arise frequently in UK workplaces. HR teams, line managers and payroll professionals often need clarity on whether overtime can be insisted upon, whether an employee has a right to be paid for it, and how overtime affects pay calculations such as holiday pay and pay in lieu of notice. Because overtime arrangements sit at the intersection of contract law, the Working Time Regulations and minimum wage compliance, the legal position can quickly become complex without clear documentation and consistent practice.

This guide explains the rules governing overtime in the UK, what makes overtime contractual, how implied terms can arise through regular working patterns, and how these rules impact wider employer obligations. It is written for HR practitioners, managers and payroll teams responsible for designing, implementing and overseeing compliant overtime policies.

Section A: UK Overtime Rules

Most UK employees have a contractual set of weekly hours, with any additional hours usually treated as overtime. These standard hours should be clearly stated in the contract of employment or written statement of particulars. UK law does not require employers to offer overtime, nor does it require employees to accept it, unless the contract creates specific obligations. As such, the legal status of overtime depends primarily on what the contract says, supported by statutory protections and well-established case law principles.

1. Contract of Employment

A well-drafted employment contract is the primary source of rights and obligations relating to overtime. It should set out:

• The employee’s standard working hours
• The circumstances in which additional hours may be required
• Whether overtime is voluntary, compulsory, guaranteed or non-guaranteed
• How overtime will be paid or otherwise compensated
• When an employer can require overtime and when an employee may refuse it

Where the contract is silent or ambiguous, disputes may arise over whether overtime is expected, compulsory, or payable at a particular rate. Courts will interpret the true agreement between the parties, which may include implied terms created through consistent working patterns or employer expectations.

2. Employment Rights Act 1996

The Employment Rights Act 1996 requires employers to provide employees with written particulars of employment, including terms governing hours of work. While the Act does not set specific overtime rules, it underpins the requirement that contractual terms—including those relating to overtime—must be transparent and agreed.

3. ACAS Guidance

ACAS publishes best-practice guidance on managing overtime, including ensuring fairness, avoiding discriminatory allocation of additional hours, and maintaining clear communication with staff. Although ACAS guidance is not legally binding, tribunals may consider it when assessing workplace reasonableness and employer conduct.

4. Case Law Principles

Courts have long recognised that contractual terms may arise not only through written documentation but also through the conduct of the parties. Key principles relevant to overtime include:

• Implied terms by custom and practice — a term may become contractual if a working arrangement is longstanding, regular, predictable and clearly accepted by both employer and employee.
• Normal remuneration for holiday pay — decisions such as Bear Scotland v Fulton and Dudley MBC v Willetts confirm that regular overtime must be included in the first four weeks of statutory holiday pay.
• True agreement over written wording — as clarified in Autoclenz Ltd v Belcher, tribunals may look beyond written terms to determine the genuine working relationship.

These cases do not make overtime automatically contractual, but they do establish the legal tests used to determine whether overtime expectations have become part of the employee’s contractual obligations.

5. National Minimum Wage Regulations

Employers must ensure that, once all hours worked—including overtime—are factored into a pay reference period, the employee’s average hourly pay does not fall below the National Minimum Wage or the National Living Wage. This obligation applies regardless of whether overtime is paid, unpaid, voluntary or expected.

Section B: Types of Overtime

Overtime arrangements can take a number of contractual forms, and understanding these distinctions is essential for determining when overtime may become contractual. Employment contracts typically define overtime as hours worked beyond the employee’s normal working hours, but the legal status of each overtime type varies depending on how the arrangement is incorporated into the employment relationship.

In UK workplaces, overtime usually falls into one of three categories: voluntary overtime, compulsory guaranteed overtime, and compulsory non-guaranteed overtime. Each type creates different rights and expectations for both employers and employees, and each carries its own implications for matters such as holiday pay, minimum wage compliance and whether regular overtime may give rise to implied contractual terms.

1. Voluntary Overtime

Voluntary overtime is where the employer is not obliged to offer additional hours and the employee is under no obligation to accept them. This type of overtime is typically used to cover occasional staff shortages, unplanned peaks in work or unexpected operational needs. Because it is genuinely optional for both parties, voluntary overtime does not normally form part of an employee’s contractual duties.

However, voluntary overtime can still become relevant to contractual entitlements. Case law on holiday pay has confirmed that where voluntary overtime is worked with sufficient regularity and predictability, it may count towards “normal remuneration” and therefore must be included when calculating the first four weeks of statutory holiday pay. This does not, by itself, make the overtime compulsory, but it does create an entitlement to have those earnings reflected in holiday pay calculations.

2. Compulsory and Guaranteed Overtime

Guaranteed overtime is where the employer is contractually required to offer additional hours and the employee is required to work them. This type of overtime is often used in roles where predictable operational surges occur, such as seasonal production cycles or recurring customer demand. Because guaranteed overtime is contractually binding on both parties, it forms part of the employee’s contractual working hours and must therefore be reflected in holiday pay calculations and minimum wage compliance.

Employees who refuse to work guaranteed overtime may be in breach of contract, exposing them to potential disciplinary action. Employers should ensure that the requirement to work guaranteed overtime is explicitly stated in the contract to avoid ambiguity.

3. Compulsory and Non-Guaranteed Overtime

Non-guaranteed overtime is where the employer is not required to offer additional hours, but when such hours are offered, the employee is contractually obliged to work them. This arrangement is common in roles where operational demands fluctuate and the employer needs the flexibility to require additional hours at short notice.

Employment contracts will often specify that the employee must work “a reasonable amount of overtime” when operationally necessary or where tasks must be completed beyond the standard shift. Because the obligation on the employee is contractual, non-guaranteed overtime can carry consequences for refusal similar to guaranteed overtime.

As with guaranteed overtime, non-guaranteed overtime must be included in the calculation of the first four weeks of statutory holiday pay, because the employee is contractually required to perform it when offered. It must also be taken into account when assessing compliance with the National Minimum Wage.

4. Avoiding Discriminatory Overtime Practices

Regardless of the overtime type, employers must ensure that overtime practices do not inadvertently disadvantage workers with protected characteristics under the Equality Act 2010. For example, employees with caring responsibilities may be disproportionately affected by compulsory overtime requirements, potentially giving rise to indirect sex discrimination claims if the arrangements are not objectively justified.

Employers should apply overtime opportunities consistently and transparently, avoiding preferential allocation that could be viewed as discriminatory. Similarly, part-time workers must not be treated less favourably than comparable full-time employees in relation to overtime opportunities or pay, unless different treatment can be objectively justified.

Section C: When Does Regular Overtime Become Contractual?

The question of when regular overtime becomes a contractual obligation is central to overtime management in UK workplaces. Under UK employment law, overtime can be contractual either because it is expressly written into the employment contract or because it becomes implied over time through consistent working patterns, assumptions and employer expectations. Understanding these principles is key to determining when an employee can be required to work additional hours and when they may have rights relating to overtime pay, holiday pay or time off in lieu.

1. Contractual Overtime Expressly Stated in the Contract

Overtime becomes contractual where the employment contract explicitly sets out the circumstances in which additional hours must be worked. A contract may state, for example, that overtime is a requirement of the role, that employees must work “reasonable additional hours” when needed, or that certain periods of the year involve extended working hours.

If a contract specifies how overtime will be paid, the conditions under which it must be worked, or the rates applicable, these terms become part of the employee’s binding contractual obligations. Even where the contract does not specify the exact number of additional hours, an explicit expectation of mandatory overtime is sufficient to make the obligation contractual.

2. Overtime as an Implied Contractual Term

Overtime may also become contractual without being written down. UK case law recognises that contractual terms can arise by implication where both parties behave over time in a way that suggests a shared understanding. This can happen when overtime is worked regularly, expected by management, and consistently accepted by the employee.

The key authority on identifying implied contractual terms is Solectron Scotland Ltd v Roper, which established that a term may be implied through custom and practice if:

• The practice is longstanding
• The practice is clear and certain
• The practice is consistently applied
• Employees could reasonably expect the practice to continue

In the context of overtime, this means that if employees have regularly worked overtime for a significant period, and it has become a predictable and accepted part of the working pattern, a tribunal may infer that the employer is contractually obliged to offer it — or that employees are contractually obliged to perform it — depending on the facts. The test is objective and focuses on the behaviour of both parties, not just on what the written contract states.

Additionally, the Supreme Court’s decision in Autoclenz Ltd v Belcher confirmed that tribunals look at the reality of the working relationship rather than the literal wording of the written contract. If the practical reality shows that overtime is expected and regularly required, this can outweigh ambiguous or contradictory written clauses.

3. Distinguishing Between an Implied Duty to Work Overtime and a Right to Overtime Pay

It is important to distinguish between overtime becoming a contractual obligation to work additional hours and overtime becoming a contractual entitlement to receive a particular level of pay. These implications are separate and depend on the exact pattern of working practices.

For example, regular overtime may imply a contractual right to have those hours reflected in holiday pay, even if it does not create a contractual obligation to work such overtime in the future. Conversely, a pattern where employees are repeatedly instructed to work overtime, and acquiesce to doing so, may imply an obligation to perform overtime even if no enhanced pay rate was historically applied.

4. Impact of Regular Overtime on Holiday Pay (Normal Remuneration)

Even where overtime is not contractual, its regularity can still have legal consequences. Key cases such as Bear Scotland v Fulton and Dudley MBC v Willetts establish that where overtime is worked with sufficient regularity, it must be included in the calculation of the first four weeks of statutory holiday pay, as part of an employee’s “normal remuneration”.

This principle applies to:

• Compulsory overtime (guaranteed or non-guaranteed)
• Regular voluntary overtime
• Regular on-call or standby payments

Holiday pay case law therefore shows that regular overtime creates financial entitlements, even if it does not become a contractual duty to work additional hours. This distinction is essential when assessing whether overtime has become contractual for different legal purposes.

5. The Role of Employer Communication and Documentation

Clear communication is crucial in preventing disputes about when overtime becomes contractual. If employers intend overtime to remain voluntary, this must be made explicit in both the contract and workplace policies. Where overtime is required only in exceptional circumstances, this should also be clarified to avoid creating patterns that may later be interpreted as predictable or expected.

Regularly reviewing work patterns allows employers to identify where overtime habits may be drifting towards implied obligations. Employers who wish to avoid creating contractual overtime must ensure that managers do not routinely rely on the same employees to undertake regular additional hours without formal agreement.

6. Employee Rights When Overtime Becomes Regular

Employees who believe that their regular working patterns indicate a contractual obligation may raise concerns if the employer later prevents overtime opportunities, changes the overtime rate or attempts to alter the arrangement without consultation. In such cases, the employee may argue that an implied contractual term existed and that a unilateral change constitutes a breach of contract.

Employees may seek advice from employment specialists where regular overtime appears to have become a core part of their role, particularly if disputes arise around overtime pay, working hours expectations or holiday pay calculations.

Section D: Employee Overtime Rights & Entitlements

Employee rights relating to overtime depend on whether overtime is contractual, voluntary or implied through custom and practice. UK employment law does not require employees to work overtime unless their contract provides for it, nor does it require employers to pay a specific overtime rate. However, employers must ensure that overtime arrangements are implemented fairly, lawfully and in a manner consistent with contractual terms, statutory protections and established working practices. Understanding the distinction between compulsory and voluntary overtime is key to determining the rights and obligations of both parties.

1. When Employees Can Be Required to Work Overtime

Employees cannot generally be compelled to work overtime unless their employment contract contains a clause requiring them to do so. If overtime is voluntary, employees retain the right to refuse additional hours without facing disciplinary action or detriment. Any negative treatment arising from a refusal to work voluntary overtime may give rise to claims under the Employment Rights Act 1996 or, in some cases, discrimination legislation.

Where overtime is compulsory—whether guaranteed or non-guaranteed—employees are contractually obliged to work the additional hours when required. A refusal to do so may amount to a breach of contract, potentially justifying disciplinary action, provided the employer acts reasonably and consistently with any contractual or policy provisions.

2. Employees’ Protection from Detriment or Discrimination

Even where overtime is contractually required, employers must avoid unlawful detriment or discriminatory practices when allocating or managing overtime. The Equality Act 2010 prohibits less favourable treatment on the basis of protected characteristics such as sex, disability, age, race or religion. Unequal access to overtime or punitive treatment for employees unable to work additional hours due to protected characteristics may constitute indirect discrimination unless the employer can demonstrate objective justification.

Part-time workers must also not be treated less favourably than comparable full-time workers in relation to overtime entitlement unless objectively justified under the Part-Time Workers (Prevention of Less Favourable Treatment) Regulations 2000.

3. Right to Overtime Pay

There is no automatic legal right to overtime pay. Employees may only claim overtime pay if:

• Their employment contract expressly provides for overtime rates
• A collective agreement establishes such entitlements
• A custom and practice has developed through regular payment at an overtime rate
• Minimum wage rules require pay for additional hours worked

Contracts may specify overtime at normal rate, enhanced rates such as “time and a half” or “double time,” or an expectation that salaried staff work occasional additional hours without extra pay. However, employers must ensure that unpaid additional hours do not result in the employee’s average hourly pay falling below the National Minimum Wage or National Living Wage once total hours worked are accounted for.

4. Overtime and the National Minimum Wage

All workers are entitled to receive at least the applicable minimum wage for every hour worked in the pay reference period. Even if a contract allows for unpaid overtime, employers must calculate average hourly pay across total hours worked—regular hours plus overtime—to ensure compliance with minimum wage legislation. Failure to do so may result in unlawful underpayment, arrears and penalties.

5. Refusing Overtime Where It Is Not Contractual

Employees are free to decline overtime where it is not required by their contract. They should not suffer detriment, be disciplined or be treated unfavourably for refusing voluntary overtime. A refusal may only justify disciplinary action where the employment contract clearly establishes a duty to work compulsory overtime and the employer’s instruction was reasonable in the circumstances.

6. Overtime Rates, Incentives and Fair Allocation

While employers are not legally required to pay enhanced overtime rates, offering competitive overtime pay can encourage voluntary participation and support workforce morale. Employers who choose to pay enhanced overtime must apply such arrangements consistently. Inconsistent overtime allocation—particularly where decisions are based on preference, assumption or bias—may create risks of discrimination or unfair treatment claims.

Workplace policies should therefore clarify how overtime opportunities are offered, prioritised and remunerated, ensuring transparency and fairness.

7. Ensuring Overtime Policies Reflect Working Practices

Employers should ensure their overtime policies and contracts accurately reflect workplace realities. Where actual working practices diverge from written terms—for example, where employees routinely work additional hours without a clear contractual provision—this may increase the risk of implied terms or contractual disputes. Regular policy reviews, employee consultations and training for line managers can help maintain consistency between written documentation and day-to-day working practices.

Section E: Can Employers Refuse to Provide Overtime?

Whether an employer can refuse to offer overtime depends primarily on the terms of the employment contract and on how overtime is managed in practice. In the absence of a contractual obligation to offer additional hours, employers generally have the discretion to decide when overtime is available. However, they must exercise this discretion lawfully, consistently and without discriminatory impact. The way overtime is offered, allocated and withdrawn can give rise to contractual implications, employee expectations and potential legal risks if not managed properly.

1. When Employers Can Lawfully Decline to Offer Overtime

Where an employment contract does not require the employer to provide overtime, they are free to decline requests for additional hours or to restrict overtime availability. This contractual freedom applies regardless of whether overtime has been offered in the past. An employer may also withdraw or reduce overtime opportunities due to operational changes, budget constraints or workforce restructuring, provided this is handled consistently and fairly.

Employers should be clear in contracts and policies that overtime is discretionary unless they intend otherwise. This helps prevent employees from developing a reasonable expectation that overtime will continue indefinitely, thereby reducing the risk of implied contractual rights arising from regular practice.

2. When Refusing Overtime May Be Unlawful

Although employers can generally refuse to provide overtime where it is not contractually guaranteed, they must avoid doing so in a way that breaches statutory protections or results in discriminatory treatment. For example:

• Withholding overtime from part-time workers while offering it to full-time staff may breach the Part-Time Workers (Prevention of Less Favourable Treatment) Regulations 2000.
• Refusing overtime opportunities disproportionately to employees with certain protected characteristics—such as employees with disabilities or caring responsibilities—may amount to indirect discrimination under the Equality Act 2010 unless objectively justified.
• Targeting specific employees for reduced overtime as a response to grievances, whistleblowing or asserting legal rights may constitute unlawful detriment under the Employment Rights Act 1996.

Any decision to restrict overtime should therefore be based on legitimate business grounds and applied consistently across the workforce.

3. Distinguishing Between Guaranteed and Non-Guaranteed Overtime Entitlements

An employer cannot refuse overtime where the contract explicitly guarantees it. Under guaranteed overtime arrangements, the employer is obliged to offer the additional hours and the employee is obliged to work them. Withdrawing guaranteed overtime without consultation and agreement may constitute a breach of contract.

In contrast, non-guaranteed overtime allows the employer discretion over when overtime is offered but obliges the employee to accept it when offered. While employers may lawfully refuse to offer such overtime, they must ensure that the withdrawal is not discriminatory, retaliatory or inconsistent with established practice in a way that might imply a contractual entitlement.

4. Managing Expectations and Overtime Patterns

Employers should ensure that internal communications and policies accurately reflect how overtime is allocated and the extent to which it is discretionary. Where employees rely on overtime to supplement income, sudden or unexplained withdrawal can lead to disputes or claims of unfair treatment. Regular audits of overtime patterns can help employers ensure that opportunities are distributed fairly, consistently and without discrimination.

Managers should also be briefed on avoiding informal practices that create unintended commitments, such as routinely offering overtime to the same individuals or implying that overtime will continue indefinitely. Without clear oversight, these patterns can lead to implied contractual rights being inferred by tribunals.

Section F: Can the Amount of Overtime Be Capped?

Employers have the right to limit, manage or cap the amount of overtime employees work, but this must be done in compliance with the Working Time Regulations 1998 (WTR), contractual terms and broader employment protections. The central legal control on working hours is the 48-hour average weekly limit, although this can be modified by opt-out agreements. Employers must also consider the impact of excessive working hours on health, safety and wellbeing, as well as ensuring that overtime practices operate fairly across the workforce.

1. The 48-Hour Weekly Limit Under the Working Time Regulations

The WTR impose a general limit of an average of 48 hours per week, calculated over a standard 17-week reference period. This limit applies to almost all workers unless they have voluntarily agreed to opt out. Employers must ensure that employees’ total working hours—including paid overtime and any required unpaid overtime—do not exceed the statutory limit unless an opt-out agreement is in place.

The 48-hour limit is calculated as an average, which means that employees may work more than 48 hours in a particular week provided that their overall average across the reference period does not exceed the statutory cap. Certain industries may use longer reference periods, and employers may agree alternative reference periods through workforce agreements where appropriate.

2. Opt-Out Agreements

Employees may voluntarily sign an opt-out agreement to disapply the 48-hour limit. Employers must ensure that:

• The opt-out is genuinely voluntary and not a condition of employment
• The agreement is in writing
• The employee is informed of their right to withdraw consent
• Withdrawal of consent can occur with up to three months’ notice, or shorter if agreed

Even where an opt-out exists, employers should avoid routinely scheduling excessive hours without considering welfare, fatigue and health and safety obligations. The duty of care under common law and the Health and Safety at Work etc. Act 1974 limits the extent to which employers can rely on opt-outs as a blanket mechanism for excessive overtime.

3. How to Calculate Average Weekly Hours

When assessing compliance with the 48-hour limit, the calculation must include:

• All paid overtime hours
• Any unpaid overtime the employee is required to perform
• All working time spent performing duties or required to be at the workplace

Voluntary unpaid overtime—such as an employee choosing to stay late to finish a task when not instructed to do so—does not count towards total working hours for the purposes of the WTR. Breaks, rest periods and periods of availability where the employee is not required to work are also excluded.

4. Employer Discretion to Cap Overtime

Employers may impose reasonable limits on overtime even where employees have opted out of the 48-hour limit. Caps may be necessary to manage staffing levels, cost control, operational planning or employee wellbeing. Employers may also set maximum overtime limits within policies, contracts or collective agreements to prevent excessive or inconsistent working patterns.

Where overtime forms part of contractual obligations—such as compulsory guaranteed or non-guaranteed overtime—employers must ensure that any cap does not breach contractual terms. Contract variations may require employee agreement or formal consultation depending on the number of employees affected and whether the change is substantial.

5. Risk of Indirect Discrimination

Although caps on overtime are generally permissible, employers must ensure that any restrictions do not disproportionately disadvantage employees with protected characteristics under the Equality Act 2010. For instance, restricting overtime in a way that disproportionately affects employees with caring responsibilities may constitute indirect sex discrimination unless the limitation can be objectively justified.

Transparent, objective criteria for allocating limited overtime can help employers mitigate legal risks and maintain fair access to additional hours across the workforce.

6. Health, Safety and Fatigue Considerations

Regardless of contractual or statutory arrangements, employers retain a duty to protect workers from harm. Excessive overtime can lead to fatigue, impaired performance and increased risk of workplace accidents. Employers should monitor working patterns closely, particularly in safety-critical roles, and intervene where working hours pose a risk to employee welfare or business operations.

Regular fatigue risk assessments, clear escalation procedures and limits on consecutive long shifts can help employers maintain a safe working environment while meeting operational needs.

Section G: Implications of Overtime on Pay & Entitlements

The question of when overtime becomes contractual is particularly important when assessing an employee’s wider entitlements. Regular overtime can significantly affect holiday pay, pay in lieu of notice, and eligibility for time off in lieu (TOIL). UK case law has established clear rules about when overtime must be included in statutory payments, especially where overtime forms part of an employee’s normal remuneration. Employers must therefore understand how different forms of overtime—compulsory, non-guaranteed and voluntary—interact with statutory employment rights and contractual obligations.

1. Holiday Pay

UK law requires that the first four weeks of statutory annual leave (the EU-derived portion under Regulation 13 of the Working Time Regulations) must reflect an employee’s normal remuneration. Case law has confirmed that “normal remuneration” includes payments that are regular, predictable and intrinsically linked to the performance of contractual duties. This includes:

• Compulsory guaranteed overtime
• Compulsory non-guaranteed overtime
• Regular voluntary overtime where it forms part of normal working patterns

Key decisions—including Bear Scotland v Fulton and Dudley MBC v Willetts—establish that employers must include overtime payments in holiday pay calculations when those payments arise with sufficient regularity. As a result, even voluntary overtime may be captured if it contributes meaningfully to an employee’s usual earnings.

Employers should therefore take into account any overtime that employees are contractually obliged to undertake or that they work frequently enough to establish a pattern. Holiday pay and pay in lieu of holiday entitlement must be based on normal pay, meaning overtime earnings should be included where they reflect the employee’s typical remuneration during a representative reference period.

2. Overtime and Time Off in Lieu (TOIL)

Instead of receiving payment for overtime worked, employees may be offered time off in lieu (TOIL). TOIL is a common arrangement in organisations that wish to manage staffing flexibility, control overtime expenditure or support better work-life balance. However, TOIL is not automatically available under UK law; it must be expressly set out in the employment contract or agreed clearly with the employee.

Employers who make TOIL available should ensure that their policies specify:

• When TOIL can be accrued
• The rate at which TOIL is earned (e.g., hour-for-hour or enhanced)
• How and when TOIL must be taken
• What happens to unused TOIL on termination of employment
• The internal process for recording and authorising overtime worked

Without clear rules, TOIL may lead to disputes about balances, availability, and whether overtime worked was authorised. Employers should also ensure that use of TOIL does not reduce pay below the National Minimum Wage across the pay reference period.

Where TOIL is offered in place of payment, employers must still account for overtime when assessing holiday pay. TOIL arrangements cannot be used to avoid obligations to reflect normal remuneration during statutory annual leave.

Section H: Summary

Overtime arrangements must be managed with clarity, consistency and compliance in mind. Whether overtime is voluntary, compulsory, guaranteed or non-guaranteed, employers should ensure that contractual terms and workplace practices align. Clear documentation helps prevent misunderstandings, while regular monitoring of overtime patterns reduces the risk of implied terms forming through custom and practice.

Understanding when overtime becomes contractual is central to managing employer obligations under UK employment law. Explicit contractual terms, combined with established working habits and expectations, may create binding obligations that affect pay entitlements, working hours compliance and holiday pay calculations. Regular overtime, even where voluntary, may be considered part of an employee’s normal remuneration and therefore must be included in holiday pay assessments in line with case law.

Employers who rely on overtime must also comply with minimum wage requirements and the Working Time Regulations, ensuring that average hourly pay does not fall below the statutory minimum and that employees do not exceed the 48-hour average weekly limit unless they have opted out. Fair allocation of overtime opportunities is essential to prevent discrimination risks and uphold workplace equality standards.

By clearly defining overtime obligations and ensuring that policy, practice and contractual terms operate consistently, employers can minimise dispute risks and maintain compliant and transparent working arrangements.

Section I: Need Assistance?

Overtime arrangements can raise complex issues for employers, particularly where working patterns evolve over time or contractual terms are unclear. Ensuring compliance with the Working Time Regulations, minimum wage rules and holiday pay obligations requires a careful understanding of how different types of overtime interact with statutory protections and contractual rights. Where uncertainty exists about whether overtime has become contractual, or how to manage overtime in a way that avoids legal risks, employers may benefit from obtaining specialist advice tailored to the specific workplace circumstances.

If you require guidance on managing overtime, interpreting contractual obligations or ensuring that working hours and pay structures remain compliant with UK employment law, professional employment law advisers can help you assess risks, clarify obligations and implement effective HR practices. Taking early advice can help prevent disputes, strengthen policy drafting and support fair, transparent decision-making.

Section J: Overtime FAQs

Can overtime be contractual?

Yes. Overtime becomes contractual when the employment contract explicitly requires the employee to work additional hours or when an implied contractual term arises through regular and consistent working practices. For example, where overtime is written into the contract as compulsory, or where an employee has routinely worked overtime over a long period and both parties behave as though this is expected, the obligation may become contractual.

What is the law on overtime in the UK?

There is no general legal requirement for employees to work overtime unless their employment contract specifically provides for it. Likewise, employers are not obliged to offer overtime unless it is contractually guaranteed. Any contractual terms must comply with the Working Time Regulations 1998, National Minimum Wage requirements and non-discrimination obligations.

Can I refuse overtime in the UK?

If your contract states that overtime is voluntary, you are free to refuse it without facing disciplinary action or detriment. If the contract specifies that overtime is compulsory (either guaranteed or non-guaranteed), refusing overtime may amount to a breach of contract, and your employer may take reasonable disciplinary action.

Can overtime become custom and practice?

Yes. If overtime is worked regularly, predictably and over a significant period, it may become an implied contractual term through custom and practice. Under the legal test established in Solectron Scotland Ltd v Roper, a working practice may become contractual if it is longstanding, consistently applied and understood by both employer and employee to be a standard part of the role.

What constitutes contractual overtime in the UK?

Contractual overtime arises when the obligation to work additional hours is expressly written into the contract or becomes implied through established working patterns. Contractual overtime may include compulsory guaranteed overtime, compulsory non-guaranteed overtime, or any regular overtime that forms a consistent part of the employee’s normal duties.

How can I determine if my regular overtime is contractual?

Consider whether your overtime is:

• Explicitly described in your contract
• Regular and predictable
• Expected by your employer
• A consistent and longstanding part of your role

If these factors apply, it may indicate an implied contractual obligation. Reviewing your contract and discussing the position with your employer can help clarify expectations.

Can my employer change the terms of my contractual overtime?

Yes, but any change to contractual terms must follow a proper procedure. Employers must consult with affected employees and, in many cases, obtain agreement before changing contractual overtime requirements. Unilateral changes may constitute a breach of contract or give rise to constructive dismissal claims if not handled correctly.

What should I do if I think my regular overtime has become contractual without a formal agreement?

You should review your contract, assess your overtime pattern and discuss your concerns with your employer. If the issue remains unresolved, you may seek guidance from an employment law adviser to determine whether an implied contractual term exists based on custom and practice.

What are my rights regarding overtime pay if it is considered contractual?

If overtime is contractual, you are entitled to receive the payment terms agreed within your contract or any applicable collective agreement. This may include enhanced overtime rates or standard pay for additional hours. Employers must also ensure that total pay complies with National Minimum Wage laws and reflects holiday pay entitlements based on normal remuneration.

How can employers avoid regular overtime becoming contractual?

Employers should:

• Clearly define overtime expectations in contracts and policies
• Avoid reliance on the same employees for regular overtime unless intended
• Document all overtime agreements and approvals
• Communicate consistently that overtime is voluntary where applicable
• Periodically review working patterns to identify emerging implied terms

Taking these steps helps employers prevent unintended contractual obligations and maintain flexibility in workforce management.

Section K: Glossary

Section L: Additional Resources

Author

Gill Laing

Gill Laing is a qualified Legal Researcher & Analyst with niche specialisms in Law, Tax, Human Resources, Immigration & Employment Law.

Gill is a Multiple Business Owner and the Managing Director of Prof Services - a Marketing & Content Agency for the Professional Services Sector.

• Gill Laing

  UK Overtime: Employer Legal Guide
• Gill Laing

  UK Overtime Pay Rules for Employers
• Gill Laing

  Holiday Pay on Overtime: Employer Legal Guide
• Gill Laing

  When Regular Overtime Becomes Contractual